The Yankees’ lifer put together some phenomenal seasons with the franchise, but his 1985 season is unforgettable
Don Mattingly’s MVP recognition:
- 1985 American League MVP
- 1986 American League MVP runner-up
- 1984 American League MVP 5th place
- 1987 American League MVP 7th place
- 1989 American League MVP 15th place
- 1994 American League MVP 18th place
- 1993 American League MVP 19th place