YEAR: 1894
SIGNIFICANCE: Jack Wadsworth of the Louisville Colonels allowed 28 singles in one game
126 years ago, Jack Wadsworth, a starting pitcher for the Louisville Colonels, was kept in the game for way too long against the Phillies. Wadsworth allowed a record-setting 28 singles in his outing. The Phillies absolutely murdered everything Wadsworth threw, breaking records for hits, runs, and total bases in a single game. This game also featured Hall of Famer Sam Thompson, who hit for the cycle and went 6-for-7 in the 29-4 demolishing of the Louisville Colonels.
After the game, it was reported that Wadsworth’s arm hung limp as people wondered why the manager left him in for so long. Wadsworth’s 1894 is one of the worst seasons for a pitcher of all time, pitching 173 IP and allowing 261 hits and 146 runs. His 7.60 ERA in 1984 is tied for the second highest single-season ERA ever for a starter with at least 150 IP.