*Player grades key: 2019 = Overall production that season, Future = Most likely highest grade in a future season
While Cam Newton deserves to be a starter in this league, it made sense for teams not to want to bring him in as the backup due to his competitive nature and the potential shift in the locker room that adding an alpha personality like his could cause. In this deal, Newton is being paid like a backup, but is guaranteed less money than Jeff Driskel, Colt McCoy, and A.J. McCarron. Even if he reaches all $7M of his incentives, that’s still less than backups Marcus Mariota ($9.1M), Mitchell Trubisky ($9.3M), and Jacoby Brissett ($21.4M) will all collect in 2020.
Newton has spent most of the offseason trying to remain patient and could have waited well into the regular season for an established QB to get hurt or benched. Although the deal isn’t worthy of the former MVP’s potential production, Newton said himself that this isn’t about money, it’s about respect. He has everything he wants presented to him in New England. The Patriots not only give Newton the opportunity to land a starting job, but also provide him with one of the few franchises that’s instantly ready to compete for the Lombardi trophy.
With the Browns reportedly being the only other team in contact for his services, Newton had to seize the opportunity to work with Bill Belichick and Josh McDaniels. Some believe Belichick has a lot to prove this season as he faces the challenge of replacing the GOAT Tom Brady, and it almost looked like Jarrett Stidham was the guy to fill those legendary shoes. The sets and formations Belichick and Josh McDaniels can now add to the playbook this season is scary as this team shifts to a more dynamic offense with Newton under center.
This move doesn’t come without its major questions though: What happens if Cam gets hurt again? If he can’t run like he used to, then how valuable can he really be? Is Bill Belichick going to try to fit Newton into the same system Brady thrived in for years, or will he add more RPOs, read-options, and designed QB runs?
The adjustment for Newton could be difficult as he transitions into a more strict environment and different offensive system, but he’s more than ready to reap the rewards of the Championship culture in Foxborough. If Newton somehow can’t mesh well into the “Patriot Way”, he can easily be cut for a small fee.
When it all comes down to it, Newton is well worth the risk, especially if he’s fully healthy again given his ability to put up MVP-caliber production. But it’s not Cam’s abilities that are in question, it’s his durability. After all, the best ability is availability. At the end of the day, Cam Newton’s one-year deal has the potential to be the best return on investment amongst any QB in the NFL in 2020. It’s also no coincidence it was announced about 15 minutes before news broke about their punishment for filming the Bengals.
FUTURE OUTLOOK: B+ (Impact player who could be Pro Bowl caliber if fully healthy)