By Jordan Howard, PSO Asst. Director of Sports Analytics
Dec 18, 2022

Jerry Rice recorded the most REC YDS (289) in Monday Night Football history 27 years ago on December 18, 1995 so it’s a great time to look at the top 5 greatest NFL offensive players of all time with him highlighting the list.



With over 100 years of NFL history dating back to 1920, there has been plenty of offensive talent on display throughout the years. Fans and players alike have seen the game grow and evolve massively, with play-styles, game plans, and schemes constantly changing to adapt with the rest of the league. So what separates the NFL’s offensive GOATs from the rest of the elite athletes? The NFL has seen a shift in the past few decades, as a sport once determined by the legs of the Running Back and the size of the Linemen is now dominated by the arm of the Quarterback and the hands of a Receiver.

Ranking athletes becomes progressively harder as the sport’s history prolongs, but each individual’s game on this list transcends anything seen before or after them. These top-5 offensive players not only had the raw skill and athletic ability to excel at the highest level, but they possessed a unique dedication to their bodies, minds, and teams that separated them from their peers– along with a decent amount of luck.

One of the largest factors in a player’s legacy is longevity, which is hard to come by in a sport as physically taxing as football. One freak play can sideline any athlete at any time, leaving fans wondering what could have been. Whether it’s luck or skill, these top-5 players were able to dominate defenses at the highest level for years, establishing themselves as the game’s greatest. Honorable mention includes: Joe Montana, Barry Sanders, Randy Moss, and Tony Gonzalez.

Here are the top 5 greatest NFL offensive players of all time. Create your own rankings below! 


PSO Rankings

1
QB TOM BRADY

TOM BRADY FACTS:

– Most Super Bowls (7) and Super Bowl MVPs (5) all-time

– 3x NFL MVP | Most Pro Bowls (15) in NFL history

– Most PASS YDS (85,929), TD (631), and Wins (246) ever

 

Tom Brady cemented himself as the NFL’s undisputed GOAT and football’s ultimate winner. His dedication to the game is unmatched as his unparalleled football IQ has carried him to the most storied career in NFL history.

https://twitter.com/PSO_Sports/status/1515471818144026628

2
WR JERRY RICE

JERRY RICE FACTS:

– Most All-Pro 1st Team (10) by WR in NFL history

– Most Career REC YDS (22,895) and REC TD (197)

– 2x NFL OPOY | 1987 NFL MVP | 3x Super Bowl Champ

 

Holding every major career record for WRs, Jerry Rice tore apart secondaries for 20 years in the NFL. His sticky hands, breakaway speed, and route running gave defensive coordinators nightmares as there was no answer for his greatness.

3
QB PEYTON MANNING

PEYTON MANNING FACTS:

– Most MVPs (5) and QB All-Pro 1st Team (7) ever

– Most GWD (54) | Most seasons (14) of 4,000+ PASS YDS

– Single-season PASS YDS (5,477) & PASS TD (55) record

 

Peyton Manning is arguably the greatest regular season player in NFL history, posting many of the most captivating single-season performances ever. The Sheriff changed the game of football forever with his audibles at the line of scrimmage and signature “Omaha” call that epitomized his brilliance.

https://twitter.com/PSO_Sports/status/1489728495722844161

4
RB EMMITT SMITH

EMMITT SMITH FACTS:

– NFL career RUSH YDS (18,355) & RUSH TD (164) leader

– Most YScm (21,579) & TOT TD (175) by a RB all-time

– 1993 NFL MVP | 3x SB Champion | 8x Pro Bowler

 

With 11 straight seasons of 1,000+ RUSH YDS, Emmitt Smith‘s greatest weapon was his longevity. There has never been a Running Back that was able to sustain greatness at his position for as long as he did throughout his career.

5
RB JIM BROWN

JIM BROWN FACTS:

– Only RB with more TD (126) than GP (118) in NFL history

– Most MVPs (3) and All-Pro 1st Team (8) by a RB

– Most Career RUSH YPG (104.3) and TD/GP (1.07) by a RB

 

As one of football’s greatest pioneers, Jim Brown took the league by storm with his aggressive style of running. Standing at 6’2″, 232 lbs, #32 was the NFL’s original power back and seemingly no defense could challenge him on the way to the end-zone.

My Rankings

Create your own 'Top 5 NFL Offensive Players Ever' rankings

 



 

Help Pro Sports Outlook continue to grow:

Share your top 5 greatest NFL offensive player rankings with friends

– Click FOLLOW for high-quality sports content delivered to your email or your platform of choice

– Follow @PSO_Sports on Twitter & Instagram | Pro Sports Outlook on YouTube, Facebook, & LinkedIn

– Get 10% off all exclusive PSO designed sports t-shirts & jerseys on FanGearNation.com: Code PSO10 at check out