By Ricky Eisenbart, PSO Director NFL Scouting
Apr 24, 2021

PSO’s original Scouting Reports strive to be uniquely valuable in evaluating a player’s future outlook by focusing on the four main subjects that summarize a player’s likelihood of succeeding at the next level including: Natural Physical Tools, College Game Film, proven Production, and overall Risk that each individual player presents to a team drafting him. For a full breakdown of PSO’s Scouting Reports, click here 

Pos: QB

Hometown: Kennesaw, GA

School: Ohio State

Class: Junior

DOB: 3/5/1999 (22)

Height: 6’2″ (48%) | Weight: 227 lbs (71%)

Hands: 9.13” (16%) | Arms: 32.5″ (65%)

Bench: N/A  | 40 Time: 4.44s (99%)

  • Transferred to OSU after losing starting QB job to Jake Fromm at Georgia
  • 20-2 record as the starting QB at OSU after transferring from Georgia
  • Heisman Finalist, 2nd-Team All-American, Big10 POTY (x2)
  • No.2 ranked HS prospect & QB in 2018 (Trevor Lawrence)
  • Ran a 4.44s 40-YD (99th percentile among QBs)

Pros

  • Great frame — 6’2.75″ (48th), 227 lbs (71st %tile)
  • Exceptional speed (4.44s 40-YD — 99th)
  • Outstanding raw arm strength
  • Sturdy and explosive lower-half
  • Quickness to shake off defenders with 1 step
  • Strong upper-body
  • Top overall prospect in 2018 ESPN 300, 2nd in composite
 

Cons

  • Relatively small hands — 9.13″ (16th %tile)

 

Grade: A+

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=UtxixTdam20&t=187s

Pros

  • Flashes superb touch and accuracy at all levels
  • Strong on-the-run thrower, worked with lots of boots/rollouts
  • Great velocity through traffic and toward the boundary
  • Hangs tough in the pocket, capable of throwing around defenders
  • Consistently worked through multiple progressions
  • Showed the arm strength to develop into a prolific vertical passer
  • Some impressive tight-window throws despite the lack of opportunity
  • Athletic and powerful rushing/scrambling threat
  • Executes option-based reads at a very high level

 

Cons

  • Needs to hasten decision-making, improve pocket awareness
  • Can hold the ball far too long in the face of rushers
  • Frustrating misses on a few relatively easy completions
  • Scheme and talent around him opened plenty of throws
  • Sometimes overconfident in his pure arm talent

 

Grade: A-

 

Pros

  • Heisman Trophy finalist, 2nd-Team All-American (2019), 2x B10 POTY
  • Led Ohio State to 2 consecutive CFP appearances (1-2 record)
  • 63:9 TD to INT ratio over 2 years at OSU (67:9 career)
  • 70% completion rate, 80.8% adjusted (2nd)
  • 19 of 22 PASS TDs in 2020 thrown 10+ yards downfield (61/89 ATT, 68.5%)
  • Completed nearly 60% of 20+ yard throws (19/32)
  • Almost 70% of passing yards came through the air
  • Elite PFF grading profile (92+ passing, intermediate, deep, clean pocket)
  • 3rd-rated QB in 2020 (93.5), 6th in 2019 (91.5)
  • Screens accounted for just 82 total PASS YDS
  • Only 18 TO-worthy plays on 622 career ATTs (2.9%)
  • Over 1,100 career RUSH YDS and 19 RUSH TD
  • 10 RUSH TD in 2019 alone

 

Cons

  • 62.9 PFF grade when pressured

 

Grade: A+

Pros

  • Exceptional production as a starter (since 2019)
  • Faced some quality defensive units in the Big Ten, CFP
  • Prototypical frame with an elite arm talent
  • Consecutive top-6, 91+ overall PFF grades
  • Shredded Clemson’s defense in 2020 Sugar Bowl (CFP Semi)
  • Brings toughness & proven ability to lead a Championship-caliber team
  • High-effort player with a sky-high ceiling as dual threat QB
  • Leadership: Team captain and led the #WeWantToPlay campaign
  • Will only be 22 years old on Draft Day
  • Impressive athletic background & prospect pedigree

 

Cons

  • Play-style will likely lead to injuries against NFL competition
  • Supported by scheme, several talented weapons and OL
  • Some struggles in the face of pressure
  • Needs to speed up his reads and decision-making
  • Limited number of tight-window throws
  • Couldn’t beat out Jake Fromm at Georgia for QB1 as a 5-star recruit
  • Ugly performances vs Indiana & Northwestern, struggled vs Clemson in 2019

 

Grade: B+

A Georgia native, Justin Fields spent most of his high school career vying with fellow Georgian Trevor Lawrence for the label of the nation’s top QB prospect. After failing to pry the starting job away from Jake Fromm at Georgia, however, Fields decided to take his talents to Columbus and replaced 1st-round QB Dwayne Haskins.

In his first season as starter, Fields tossed 41 TDs and only 3 INTs while leading the Buckeyes to a 13-0 record and the 2nd CFP seed. Defeated in the classic showdown by none other than Trevor Lawrence and Clemson, Fields led his team back to the CFP in 2020 despite a 6-game schedule, and Ohio State was afforded a rematch — which Fields took full advantage of, turning in a performance for the ages.

While clearly possessing immense physical traits, Fields’ most glaring weaknesses relate to processing speed and pocket awareness. In need of speeding up his internal clock, he’s also failed to identify blitzes on occasion, holding onto the ball far too long under duress. The concern is warranted considering the stout OL in front of him, yet he’s proven more than capable of throwing with bodies surrounding him or breaking the pocket and eating up yardage with his legs. 

Though certainly important to note, these flaws often get ironed out with experience and maturity. Not to say they aren’t of legitimate concern, but the on-field production and raw ability Fields showcased over 2 whole seasons far outweigh them. Not only does he possess a cannon with impressive accuracy and touch, but he hangs tough in the pocket and attacks every area of the field with precision. His athleticism will need to be exploited if he plays right away, but there’s more than enough evidence to suggest he’s capable of growing and commanding a pro-level offense.

Pro Comp: QB Robert Griffin III (Free Agent)

Projected Round: Top-10 Pick

Prime Destinations: NYJ, SF, ATL, DET, DEN, NE, CHI

OVERALL Grade: A

 

 

 

Share this Justin Fields scouting report with friends and follow for more great sports content!