By Audrey Wacker, PSO Asst. Director of Baseball Content
Feb 06, 2022

February 6, 2022 marks the 127th birthday of the Great Bambino so it’s a great time to look at the Yankees’ top-5 greatest players of all time with him headlining the star-studded list.



As a franchise that can be traced back to the beginning of the 1900s, the New York Yankees have created a rich history full of wins and historic players. They have accumulated more World Series wins than any other team, and are the only franchise to win 4 years in a row, a feat they accomplished twice. It is no secret that the Yankees are the wealthiest team in the league, so it is safe to say that they are known for their big wins, big players, and even bigger money. Honorable mention includes: CP Mariano Rivera, C Yogi Berra, SP Whitey Ford, & RF Reggie Jackson

Here are the top 5 greatest Yankees Players of all time. Create your own rankings below! 


PSO Rankings

1
OF/SP Babe Ruth

Babe Ruths’ Yankees facts:

– 4x WS Champ, 2x All-Star, 1923 AL MVP, 10x AL HR leader

– Most HR (714) in Yankees history; 1st to 500 MLB HR

– Highest career OPS (1.164) & SLG (.690) in MLB history

 

It would be nearly impossible to exclude a player from this list who still holds multiple league and franchise records after nearly a century, illustrating how Babe Ruth‘s feats have truly stood the test of time.

2
1B Lou Gehrig

Lou Gehrig’s Yankees facts:

– 2x MVP, 7x All-Star (straight), 6x WS Champ

– 3x MLB HR, 4x MLB RBI, & 3x MLB Runs leader

– Most career RBI (1,995) & XBH (1,190) in Yankees history

 

Lou Gehrig never shied away from the plate, consistently topping the league in a plethora of batting categories. When combined with his appearances in 2,130 consecutive games, the Iron Horse was arguably one of the most reliable players to ever step foot on the field.

3
CF/1B Mickey Mantle

Mickey Mantle’s Yankees facts:

– 3x MVP, 20x All-Star, 1962 Gold Glove, 7x WS Champ

– 1956 MLB HR (52) & RBI (130) leader, 5x league Runs leader

– Most HR (18), RBI (40), & Runs (42) in MLB WS history

 

Refusing to crumble under pressure, Mickey Mantle delivered when it mattered most, hitting the Yankees into seven World Series rings.

4
CF Joe DiMaggio

Joe DiMaggio’s Yankees facts:

– 3x MVP, 13x All-Star (every year), 9x WS Champ

– 1937 MLB HR (46) & Runs (151) leader, 2x MLB RBI leader

– Longest hitting streak in MLB history (56 GS)

 

Joe DiMaggio‘s 1941 56-game hitting streak is one that baseball may never see get broken, as no player has even come within ten games of smashing it, so with a record like that, Joltin’ Joe permanently cemented his name in MLB history.

5
SS Derek Jeter

Derek Jeter’s Yankees facts:

– 13x All-Star, 5x Gold Glove, 5x Silver Slugger, 1996 ROY

– 5x WS Champ (2000 MVP), 2x MLB Hits leader

– Most career Playoff Hits (200) & Runs (111) of all-time

 

As great as he was in the regular season, Derek Jeter was even better when the lights shined the brightest in October (and November) as he helped the Yankees secure five World Series titles, setting multiple records in the meantime.

My Rankings

Create your own 'Greatest Yankees Players of All-Time'

 



 

Share your Top 5 all-time Yankees Player rankings with friends, FOLLOW for more sports content, and comment your thoughts below!